Originally Posted by
Taksin
The ladies play three sets rather than five in tennis. The ladies play off tees at least a hundred yards closer in golf. They do heptathlon rather than a decathlon. I personally love watching all those sports
Bear in mind we've reached the point where the leaders of our political parties can't even define what a woman is. I don't think anyone here is suggesting women shouldn't want to play football or be allowed to, but something else is happening. The atmosphere is developing where the only thought we are allowed to think is that they should be equal and the only reason they aren't equal is because of some kind of oppression or disadvantage imposed upon women.
Whilst women have no doubt received many disadvantages, the long history of football has emerged in significant part from the disadvantages imposed upon working class men. It has emerged organically and passionately, in partnership with the fans - particularly live spectators not TV viewers - and not as the result of an ideology about the way the world ought to be.
The people at Wimbledon decided they should be paid equally despite obvious differences in quality, amount of work put in, level of competition, and revenue generation (public interest). The same kinds of people don't think we need to be told who 'Engand' are anymore, or even who 'Liverpool FC' are because it would be sexist. These new attitudes are sources of irritation and open to criticism, in my opinion.
If you think the problem will be solved when England women catch up with England you will have a wait on your hands that will outlive you and me and therefore you can never be proved wrong in your lifetime. The reparations must go on forever.
I would also say football is a special category because so much of it is so incredibly shit. If you've sat through 90mins of Dunfermline vs St Mirren on a waterlogged pitch in mid January I believe you are entitled to wonder what the point is to watching women struggle to make the game beautiful. Even the European Cup Finals are quite boring unless you have half the city descending on Madrid or Paris
To just say 'they should be equal' is a sophistry
Spot on, well said.
It's unequal equality.
Most women's sports are off-shoots of the men's games - which men have fought hard for.
The women, on the other hand, have just waltzed in and are reaping the benefits of something they have never had to fight for.
(In my opinion)
There's too much confusion, I can't get no relief
Bookmarks