Personally, no - but can see why others would and respect their opinion.
Isak "moves the needle" quite a bit, plus we now have four centre-backs again (though I want another given Leoni's experience, the Konaté situation and Gomez's injury record) and a good midfield - plus the attack (with Isak) would leave us with Gakpo, Isak, Ekitike, Salah, Chiesa with Wirtz behind it and Ngumoha getting minutes here and there.
We'd be close. Given where the squad is right now, I'd far rather have the needle-moving, top-tier specialists because of our current position and circumstances. There have been other times in our history where I would absolutely have plumped for the numbers/depth side of the coin in the binary "one or the other" scenario but I'll take the lad who might get us the extra 5-8 points in key fixtures or get us through a Champion's League knockout tie just now.