Other games - May

[RedMagic]

Nope, that's incorret. For 6th place to gain a CL spot Villa HAVE to finish 5th and win the Europa.

If we somehow beat Brentford last day, and Villa lose, but have already won the Europa, then 6th place will qualify for the CL.

We're both correct as the PL would have got six spots if Villa finished outside the top four but won the EL.

[RedMagic]

Newcastle go 3-0 up. Asula with the goal.

[RedMagic]

West Ham get a goal back via a fantastic Castellanos goal.

[Crimson Dynasty]

Nope, that's incorret. For 6th place to gain a CL spot Villa HAVE to finish 5th and win the Europa.

If we somehow beat Brentford last day, and Villa lose, but have already won the Europa, then 6th place will qualify for the CL.

Actually, this is incorrect.

Based on all previous seasons when this has happened, if the Europa League winner finishes within the top CL spots in their league (be it top 4 or 5, depending on the league), then that league doesn't automatically get an extra spot.

You only get an extra spot if the Europa League winner finishes outside the top CL spots - such as happened last season when Spuds won the Europa League but finished far outside the top places.
And even then they still have to get into the group phase proper in a pre-qualifying round of games.

Same would apply if a team won the Champions League itself but finished outside the qualifying places as we did in Istanbul.

It used to be an automatic qualification (as happened for us then) but somewhere along the way they made it that if you won one of those European trophies but finished outside your qualifying spots, you'd get in, but only through the pre-group qualifying matches.

So in present day scenario, the only way the Premier League could have gotten a 6th spot would have been had Villa finished outside the top 5 but then won the Europa League.
Following their victory over us last Friday, that isn't going to happen as the worst spot they can finish at is 5th place.

So only 5 teams will qualify for Champions League from the Premier League this season regardless of whether the Europa League winner is among them or not.

(5 qualified last season (instead of the apportioned 4) because the eventual EL winner finished outside the top 4.
Ironically, we have the Spuds to thank for if we do happen to qualify as 5th place finishers as they're winning the Europa League (along with playing the Mancs in the final) factored into giving the Premier league an extra spot for this season)

[Crimson Dynasty]

We're both correct as the PL would have got six spots if Villa finished outside the top four but won the EL.

"..outside the top five."

And no, YOU are correct, and he wasn't.

The PL would have gotten 6 spots (ONLY) if Villa had finished outside the top five but won the EL.

Such as happened with Spurs last season (when the PL had 4 apportioned spots but eventually had 5 teams competing because the Spuds won the EL despite finishing 17th in the league)